The Heracleidae is one of Euripides’ odder plays. The episodes of the story hang loosely together, with no single unifying theme or main character. Iolaus, a focal character for the first two thirds, suddenly turns into a comic buffoon, then a soldier whose youth has been magically restored, then disappears. Eurystheus, the standard one-dimensional villain, is allowed to present his case in the very last scene, and by his death becomes one of the holy guardians of Athens. Even the tragic tone of the whole play comes and goes in a rather confusing manner. While all of this may be part of Euripides’ stance on Greek politics, it does not make for a particularly compelling and lasting drama. However, two characters stand out, to me at least, as more compelling than the play they found themselves in. These are the two female characters, who in some ways are polar opposites, yet who share one surprising characteristic: religious doubt.
First on stage is Macaria, the daughter of Heracles. Though the Athenians have agreed to give sanctuary to Heracles’ children and protect them from the wicked Eurystheus, they have learned from an oracle that they will only be able to defeat Eurystheus in battle if they first sacrifice a virgin maiden. Macaria offers herself as the sacrifice, in the hope that by giving up a happy life of her own, she will give a happy life to her brothers. In a certain sense, Macaria represents a standard ideal of feminine virtue – like Alcestis, she sacrifices herself for the men in her life. But there is no denying that she has courage and a strong will. She comes out of the temple to address the men and say what she will do, rather than waiting for them to come and command her. And she is indignent at the suggestion that she and her sisters draw lots to see who will be sacrificed. Her life and her death is hers to give, not something to be taken by the luck of the draw. Moreover, her final words reveal a surprising motive for her sacrifice:
Afterward: is there / An afterward? I hope not. If there’s then / No end to all our troubles, where do we / Go on from there – since death itself, they say, / Supplies the cure for everything that ails?
This is a surprisingly unorthodox statement from a classically virtuous heroine. The continuing life of the dead is a standard element of Greek mythology, with multiple heroes making trips to the underworld to speak to and occasionally rescue the dead. Yet Macaria hopes that no such life exists, that death is a true end. And this seems to make up a large part of her motivation. Yes, one could argue that she wants to die to escape earthly suffering. But what seems even more important to me is the idea that, if death is truly the end, one’s death takes on a much larger significance than it would have otherwise in determining the meaning of one’s life. Death is the end, not simply the last moment, but the fulfillment, of one’s life, and so one needs a good death to give the ultimate meaning to one’s life. For this reason, Macaria seizes on the chance to turn her death into a sacrifice. She makes her death entirely her choice, and done for a noble reason, and so gives meaning to her death, and consequently to her life too.
After Macaria is taken offstage to be sacrificed, the second female character enters: Alcmene, Heracles’ mother and Macaria’s grandmother. Alcmene is hardened and feisty. From the minute she steps on stage, you know she is not going to sacrifice herself for anyone. The suffering of her family has made her angry, at the gods no less than her enemies. She speaks begrudgingly about Zeus:
It’s not for me to criticize Zeus, but / Still he knows best if he’s played fair with me.
And after the battle is won, she claims that Zeus took his time in helping her. Her bitterness comes to a head, however, when she meets the man who has been bent on destroying her family. Furious that Eurystheus was not killed in the battle, she demands that he be executed now. After some complicated legal and pious arguments (which I will not go into here), the Athenians agree to execute Eurystheus at Alcmene’s command. This revenge is presented as one of Alcmene’s main purposes in life, her way of finding justice for her family. She feels abandoned by the gods and so sees no other course than to take judgement into her own hands. She refuses to listen to the pious arguments of the Athenians against killing a prisoner of war, and is even willing to kill her enemy with her own hand. While it is at times refreshing to see a woman unbound by the rather strict classical notions of feminine propriety, ultimately Alcmene becomes a horrifying character. Bitter against the gods who abandoned her, and bitter against the enemy who wronged her, she will wield the sword until her revenge is complete.
These woman could hardly be more different. One gives up her own life to save another’s, the other takes the life of another. Yet what is surprising is that both are motivated by some kind of religious unorthodoxy to take matters into their own hands. Both take an unusual view, that the meaning of their lives is up to them, unaffected by the gods or a life after death. The similarities end, however, with the meaning that they choose to make for themselves. The one chooses a sacrificially heroic death, the other a deeply desired revenge – and it is left to the audience to judge between them.