Aside

You’ve probably noticed that I haven’t posted anything for a few months. My well of ideas for blog posts seems to have run dry, so I’ve decided to stop blogging for the foreseeable future. I’ll keep writing, but I’m going to focus on something more private (at least for now). Thank you for reading and following this blog over the last four years.

Access Review: Monticello

Tags

, , , , ,

Overall, I would say Monticello does a pretty good job of making itself wheelchair accessible. The visitors center is a modern building with standard ADA compliance (handicapped parking, step-free entrances, elevators, etc.). The cellars and first floor of the historic house are accessible by ramp. The second and third floors are not accessible, but you have to pay extra for a special upstairs tour anyway. The bigger difficulty is getting between the house and visitors center, and around the grounds.

Shuttles run between the house and visitors center, and there is a wheelchair accessible vehicle. I took the shuttle on the way down. The lift worked perfectly, and the driver operated the lift and the restraints confidently and quickly. The ride was a bit bumpy, and I had a little difficulty holding my neck still, but for such a short ride I didn’t mind. Some visitors prefer to walk rather than take the shuttle (a distance of about three fifths of a mile), as I did on the way up. However, the walking trail is not very accessible. It is a gravel path that becomes fairly steep in places. The beginning of the path at the visitors center starts with what is almost a step. It is impossible for a power wheelchair to get over. A manual wheelchair might be able to navigate it, but then would most likely have difficulty with the steep path later on. Seeing this, and still wanting to go at a more leisurely pace than riding the shuttle, I headed up the road reserved for the shuttles. Pedestrians are technically not allowed on this road (as I was informed by a shuttle driver who passed me). If you are worried about being seen by drivers on a narrow, curvy road, you might not want to go this way. But the road is wide enough for the shuttle to comfortably pass you, and I enjoyed slowly taking in the scenic views.

Finally, the paths around the historic house are variable, and it will really depend on your individual situation how comfortable you are navigating them. Again, these paths are gravel, and in some places are fairly steep. In my power wheelchair, I had no problem getting around, but it might be more difficult in a manual wheelchair. These paths do reach almost every site on the grounds without steps. Jefferson’s grave is farther out from the house, and I did not try to stop there, so I cannot comment on its accessibility.

Duality of Selfhood in Middlemarch

Tags

,

In the first two books of Middlemarch, George Eliot sets out what will become the main themes of the novel, as well as introducing the characters and plot lines. What struck me most this time around were the different kinds of selves that she describes. In chapter 21, the narrator writes about Dorothea beginning to realize the true difficulties of her marriage:

We are all of us born in moral stupidity, taking the world as an udder to feed our supreme selves: Dorothea had early begun to emerge from that stupidity, but yet it had been easier to her to imagine how she would devote herself to Mr. Casaubon, and become wise and strong in his strength and wisdom, than to conceive with that distinctness which is no longer reflection but feeling – an idea wrought back to the directness of sense, like the solidity of objects – that he had an equivalent centre of self, whence the lights and shadows must always fall with a certain difference.

Earlier, in chapter 15, the narrator is introducing her other main character, Mr. Lydgate. Describing a moment of folly, she writes,

He knew that this was like the sudden impulse of a madman – incongruous even with his habitual foibles. No matter! It was the one thing which he was resolved to do. He had two selves within him apparently, and they must learn to accommodate each other and bear reciprocal impediments. Strange, that some of us, with quick alternate vision, see beyond our infatuations, and even while we rave on the heights, behold the wide plain where our persistent self pauses and awaits us.

The contrast between these two passages, between the supreme self and the persistent self, struck me. Both paint a picture of a duality of selves, though the first passage is describing two people, while the second passage describes the double self of a single person. In both passages, the essential, though difficult and perhaps uncommon, thing is the ability to recognize this duality.

According to the first passage, all of us are inherently selfish, viewing our own self as supreme above any other. To become an adult is to learn to feel the selfhood of other people, as instinctively as we feel our own. Thus, it is easy for Dorothea to imagine how her self may grow through contact with Mr. Casaubon. It is more difficult to imagine Mr. Casaubon’s self independent from her own, to feelingly understand the struggles of his mind which may take a completely different view than hers. Yet such imagining and understanding is the task she is faced with.

The second passage develops a related idea. Though all of us are born trying to feed our supreme selves, some of us have the ability to detach, and view all our whims and follies through the eyes of a more persistent and stable self. We may need to learn how to feel more deeply the selves of others, but we also need a way to not get too caught up in our deep feelings about our own selves. Because Mr. Lydgate, for example, has such a viable persistent self, he survives a dramatic end to his foolish romantic passion and returns to his deeper passion for scientific discovery.

Reading the second passage, I wonder if the idea of the persistent self is perhaps a way out of the prison of the supreme self. Those who, like Mr. Lydgate, are able to have this kind of double vision of themselves might be better able to show a similar patience with other selves. Those who are in the habit of seeing themselves from a distance might find the distance between themselves and another person less of an insurmountable barrier to understanding, might find it easier to bear with the follies of others just as they bear with their own. However, for now I will leave that as only a question or possibility, as I follow how the ideas of the supreme self and the persistent self play out in the rest of Middlemarch.

The Houses of the Presidents

Tags

, , , , , ,

Visiting the houses of early presidents seems to have become a theme in my recent travels. In the last few months, I have been to George Washington’s Mount Vernon, Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello, and James Madison’s Montpelier. Although all three houses were inherited, inhabited, and expanded by men who were both founding fathers and presidents of the new United States (and who apparently liked to name their homes after mountains), I had a very different experience in each, and learned about the distinct personalities of these three men.

At Mount Vernon, I got the impression that George Washington focused his energies on creating a financially viable plantation. The house looked elegant, but, for instance, had wood dressed to look like stone, as a cost-saving measure. Where many plantations failed because they only grew tobacco, Washington diversified his crops and other products, in order to make as much money as possible. This perspective gave Washington interesting views on slavery (and made for an interesting tour focused on slavery). While he regarded slavery as an evil, he thought that immediate emancipation would send former slaves into poverty, and thus did not pursue emancipation as a political policy. However, on his own plantation, he trained his slaves to have various skills, so that they would be able to support themselves once they were free. (Washington was the only southern president to free his slaves, albeit in his will and after the death of his wife). At the same time, Washington was a frugal man and fed his slaves very little, until an overseer pointed out that hungry slaves steal food and so end up costing more than well-fed slaves. All in all, a concern with money seems to have been one of Washington’s main motivations in many of his actions. Whether this quality is better named greed or financial acuity is not something I can answer after a mere house tour.

Thomas Jefferson, in contrast, died in debt and his heirs were forced to sell Monticello. Yet it is Monticello that is now a UNESCO World Heritage Site, and indeed, as far as the house itself, this was the most impressive house of the three. I’m sure someone more versed in architecture than I could have better appreciated Jefferson’s design. I myself was particularly impressed by the collections of books and curiosities that filled the house, from scientific instruments to animal fossils to visual artworks. Everything showed Jefferson as a man of the Enlightenment, valuing knowledge above all else. The dining room would have been arranged with several smaller tables in the manner of a French cafe, rather than the customary single long table, to promote deeper conversations. From the tour guides, I learned more about Jefferson’s many interests and detailed records of every part of his estate. In any given day, he may have recorded the temperature, the weights of crops and animals, soil conditions, architectural designs for various buildings, or notes on his substantial library, as well as worked on his technological inventions, such as the swivel chair. Indeed, he had an interest in so many subjects, and studied them all so consistently, that he came across as rather manic.

Montpelier, however, was my favorite house to visit, as I found Madison the most interesting man (though I may be biased, as he seemed to have a similar personality to me). Though only 5’2″ and rather prone to physical illness, Madison was a thoughtful and eloquent philosopher. As an introvert, he often let his wife act as the witty leader of social engagements, preferring to take time to think through an issue and write, rather than talk, about it. Where Jefferson drafted the fiery Declaration of Independence to begin the fight for independence, it was Madison who drafted the Constitution, doing the harder work of creating a system of government once was independence was won, and making a careful argument for his ideas in the Federalist Papers. In Montpelier, you can see Madison’s library where he worked on the Constitution, full of the classics that influenced him, with a window looking out onto the Blue Ridge Mountains. At the time, this would have been the frontier of the known world, and so a fitting place for Madison to explore the frontiers of political philosophy.

The Wild Justice of Women

Tags

, , , , ,

Once again, Euripides has surprised me with the way his plays upset traditional gender roles.  His female characters are consistently stronger and more courageous than the men, who often come across as wimps.  The play Hecuba portrays this contrast especially artfully, with the two halves of the story forming a kind of mirror image.

Hecuba, the former queen of Troy, has been deposed by the conquering Greeks, her city destroyed, and her husband and nearly all of her children killed.  Euripides’ play focuses on the deaths of her two remaining children.  In the first half, the Greek army sacrifices Hecuba’s daughter Polyxena to the ghost of Achilles.  While honoring their dead compatriot does play a role in this decision, the Greek army is also influenced by some decidedly less heroic motivations: political concerns over how best to preserve their society, as well as the practical consideration of getting the gods to give them a favorable wind.  One could argue that fear is their primary motive.  From the speech of Odysseus (the main proponent of this dreadful human sacrifice), it seems that the Greeks are afraid of not being able to sail home, and of what their society will devolve into if they do not give proper honor to the men who deserve it.  By contrast, Polyxena goes fearless to her death.  She walks to her execution with the regal bearing of a queen, and she herself bares her breast to the executioner’s sword.  In fact, the Greek soldiers are so impressed by her courage that they take special care to give her the honorable funeral she deserves.

The second half of the play also depicts an army performing a horrific human sacrifice, but this time the gender roles are reversed.  Immediately after the death of her daughter, Hecuba learns that her only living son, Polydorus, has been slain by Polymnester, the man who took him in since he was too young to fight in the Trojan War.  And Polymnestor has broken the sacred guest-host relationship for no baser a motivation than greed for gold.  Hecuba demands that her son’s death be avenged.  Agamemnon, the commander of the Greek army, privately reveals that he sympathizes with Hecuba, but cannot be openly seen helping Greece’s Trojan enemies.  (Once again, the Greek man comes off as an unheroic coward.)  So Hecuba takes matters into her own hands.  Gathering her women together, she tricks Polymnestor into visiting her with his two young sons.  Her army of women then slaughters Polymnestor’s sons and blinds Polymnestor himself.  In this scene, however, though the executioners are women, they are the ones who act with manly strength and fearlessness, while Polymnestor is reduced to bestial behavior, entirely lacking in the dignified resolution of Polyxena.

I will not argue that Hecuba’s revenge does not take a barbarically cruel form.  The image of mothers turning into child-killers, murdering young boys even as they coo over them, is chillingly disturbing.  Yet at the same time, the symmetry between the two halves of the play pushes a comparison between the Greek army and the army of Hecuba, in both scenes portraying the female characters as more courageous, more manly than the men.  Moreover, it seems to me that there is at least a question of whether Hecuba has a more righteous motive than her enemies.  While the Greeks are motivated by political pragmatism, Hecuba is trying to make some kind of sense of her extreme suffering.  Throughout the play, Hecuba keeps bringing up good and evil, how good and evil are immutable and will ultimately come to light, and it often feels as though she is trying to convince herself.  Revenge may be a wild justice, but it is still a kind of justice, and Hecuba seems to feel that only such cruel revenge, such wild justice, will justify the wild injustice of her own life.

Sense and Sensibility?

Tags

, , , ,

In this post about the Greek tragedy Hippolytus, I am not going to try to connect Euripides and Jane Austen.  However, Austen has given us a pithy dichotomy that provides a framework for thinking about Hippolytus.  One of the main themes of the play is the virtue of being σώφρων (sophron), which literally means “of sound mind,” prudent, or, one might say, sensible.  Out of this basic meaning comes the idea that a healthy mind is able to control the lower passions, so that σώφρων extends to also mean temperate, moderate, self-controlled, and (in reference to a very specific passion) chaste.  Throughout Hippolytus, the titular character paints himself as the most σώφρων of men.  The virgin Hippolytus shuns the company of women, worshipping Aphrodite from afar, as he puts it.  He is close, rather, to the goddess Artemis, and so spends all his time hunting – but he does not eat what he kills, avoiding the passion of gluttony as well.

The σώφρων Hippolytus is contrasted with his stepmother, Phaedra.  Though Phaedra also tries to be σώφρων, she finds herself falling in love with her stepson, struck down as if by a disease.  Try as she might, she cannot subdue this passion, and so resorts to the only method of self-control she sees as effective: suicide.  If her life has been overwhelmed by passion, then the only way to control that passion is to end her life.  And in order to preserve her reputation as a σώφρων woman, she hides the reason for her death.  She leaves a note for her husband, accusing Hippolytus of raping her, so that she will be seen as a pure victim, not as consumed with a sordid passion.

The play is often read as a dichotomy between Hippolytus, the σώφρων one, and Phaedra, the passionate one – one might say, between sense and sensibility.  While this could have been the purport of the original myth, it seems to me that Euripides upsets such a simple reading, calling into question what it really means to be σώφρων.  I would suggest that a more fruitful dichotomy would represent the two characters as each being σώφρων, but in very different ways.

On the one hand, Hippolytus is σώφρων in the more basic sense.  He has a sound mind, and his passions are subordinate to his mind – his soul is properly ordered.  In the beginning of the play, Hippolytus gives his view that someone who is naturally σώφρων is more virtuous than someone who has to work hard at it.  This statement would be nonsensical if Hippolytus was talking about self-control.  What would it mean for someone to have a natural ability to control and subdue their natural passions?  Rather, Hippolytus is talking about someone like himself, who has such a healthy mind that it doesn’t need to work to subdue the passions – the passions naturally let the mind direct them to a wholesome object.  Thus, Hippolytus is chaste, not because he controls his desire for women, but because he has no such desire in the first place.

In the character of Phaedra, Euripides asks the obvious question.  What happens when someone does have unhealthy desires?  If the desire occurs against the person’s will, and if the person finds a way to control that desire, can they still be considered σώφρων?  Phaedra is clearly not naturally of sound mind, as Hippolytus is, but her whole narrative arc is an attempt to control the horrifying passion that she finds herself afflicted with against her will.  Granted, her ultimate suicide is an extreme, but it still seems an example of self-control, of an attempt to be σώφρων not naturally, like Hippolytus, but through a harsh and violent subduing of her passion.  Let me be clear, I’m not arguing that Phaedra is a paragon of being σώφρων.  Her posthumous accusation of Hippolytus makes it seem that she may have been more concerned about appearing σώφρων than being σώφρων, which is evidence of a mind more disordered than σώφρων.  But at the very least, Euripides is raising the question of what it really means to be σώφρων, bringing into tension those who may naturally have a sound mind and those who have to work at self-control.

Of Religious Doubt and Meaning-Making Women

Tags

, , , ,

The Heracleidae is one of Euripides’ odder plays.  The episodes of the story hang loosely together, with no single unifying theme or main character.  Iolaus, a focal character for the first two thirds, suddenly turns into a comic buffoon, then a soldier whose youth has been magically restored, then disappears.  Eurystheus, the standard one-dimensional villain, is allowed to present his case in the very last scene, and by his death becomes one of the holy guardians of Athens.  Even the tragic tone of the whole play comes and goes in a rather confusing manner.  While all of this may be part of Euripides’ stance on Greek politics, it does not make for a particularly compelling and lasting drama.  However, two characters stand out, to me at least, as more compelling than the play they found themselves in.  These are the two female characters, who in some ways are polar opposites, yet who share one surprising characteristic: religious doubt.

First on stage is Macaria, the daughter of Heracles.  Though the Athenians have agreed to give sanctuary to Heracles’ children and protect them from the wicked Eurystheus, they have learned from an oracle that they will only be able to defeat Eurystheus in battle if they first sacrifice a virgin maiden.  Macaria offers herself as the sacrifice, in the hope that by giving up a happy life of her own, she will give a happy life to her brothers.  In a certain sense, Macaria represents a standard ideal of feminine virtue – like Alcestis, she sacrifices herself for the men in her life.  But there is no denying that she has courage and a strong will.  She comes out of the temple to address the men and say what she will do, rather than waiting for them to come and command her.  And she is indignent at the suggestion that she and her sisters draw lots to see who will be sacrificed.  Her life and her death is hers to give, not something to be taken by the luck of the draw.  Moreover, her final words reveal a surprising motive for her sacrifice:

Afterward: is there / An afterward?  I hope not.  If there’s then / No end to all our troubles, where do we / Go on from there – since death itself, they say, / Supplies the cure for everything that ails?

This is a surprisingly unorthodox statement from a classically virtuous heroine.  The continuing life of the dead is a standard element of Greek mythology, with multiple heroes making trips to the underworld to speak to and occasionally rescue the dead.  Yet Macaria hopes that no such life exists, that death is a true end.  And this seems to make up a large part of her motivation.  Yes, one could argue that she wants to die to escape earthly suffering.  But what seems even more important to me is the idea that, if death is truly the end, one’s death takes on a much larger significance than it would have otherwise in determining the meaning of one’s life.  Death is the end, not simply the last moment, but the fulfillment, of one’s life, and so one needs a good death to give the ultimate meaning to one’s life.  For this reason, Macaria seizes on the chance to turn her death into a sacrifice.  She makes her death entirely her choice, and done for a noble reason, and so gives meaning to her death, and consequently to her life too.

After Macaria is taken offstage to be sacrificed, the second female character enters: Alcmene, Heracles’ mother and Macaria’s grandmother.  Alcmene is hardened and feisty.  From the minute she steps on stage, you know she is not going to sacrifice herself for anyone.  The suffering of her family has made her angry, at the gods no less than her enemies.  She speaks begrudgingly about Zeus:

It’s not for me to criticize Zeus, but / Still he knows best if he’s played fair with me.

And after the battle is won, she claims that Zeus took his time in helping her.  Her bitterness comes to a head, however, when she meets the man who has been bent on destroying her family.  Furious that Eurystheus was not killed in the battle, she demands that he be executed now.  After some complicated legal and pious arguments (which I will not go into here), the Athenians agree to execute Eurystheus at Alcmene’s command.  This revenge is presented as one of Alcmene’s main purposes in life, her way of finding justice for her family.  She feels abandoned by the gods and so sees no other course than to take judgement into her own hands.  She refuses to listen to the pious arguments of the Athenians against killing a prisoner of war, and is even willing to kill her enemy with her own hand.  While it is at times refreshing to see a woman unbound by the rather strict classical notions of feminine propriety, ultimately Alcmene becomes a horrifying character.  Bitter against the gods who abandoned her, and bitter against the enemy who wronged her, she will wield the sword until her revenge is complete.

These woman could hardly be more different.  One gives up her own life to save another’s, the other takes the life of another.  Yet what is surprising is that both are motivated by some kind of religious unorthodoxy to take matters into their own hands.  Both take an unusual view, that the meaning of their lives is up to them, unaffected by the gods or a life after death.  The similarities end, however, with the meaning that they choose to make for themselves.  The one chooses a sacrificially heroic death, the other a deeply desired revenge – and it is left to the audience to judge between them.

Medea: An Unexpected Hero

Tags

, , , , ,

medea-1882(Note: I am currently part of a study group reading through the complete plays of Euripides, so I am hoping to write a blog post to accompany each play we read, starting with this post on Medea.)

It takes a uniquely talented writer to make a heroine out of a woman who kills her own children, yet this is exactly what Euripides does in Medea.  A modern writer might make the character of Medea an anti-heroine, yet it seems to me that Euripides avoids this path, giving Medea instead classically heroic characteristics.  This is signaled through the surprising ending of the play, in which Euripides makes unusual use of the device of deus ex machina.  Now a standard literary term for any new element in a plot that solves a difficult problem too easily, deus ex machina originally referred to a very specific device in Greek drama: a machine that lifted actors above the stage so that they would appear particularly god-like when playing a god (hence deus ex machina, the god in the machine).  The actor playing the god would usually appear only at the end of the play, resolving the dilemmas of the plot and often instituting some kind of religious rite, thus tying the story to the customs of the present day.  In an unexpected twist, Medea herself takes the role of the god in Euripides’ play.  She appears in the machine, that is, in the dragon-pulled chariot of her grandfather the sun god, rebukes her husband Jason for driving her to kill their children, and exonerates herself by setting up a religious cult in honor of the children.  For all intensive purposes, Medea appears as a god.

This would have been no less disturbing to the original Athenian audience, who were so troubled by the play that they gave it last place in that year’s competition.  Medea was a barbarian, a woman, and a sorceress, altogether outside the boundaries of good society.  She may be considered the embodiment of passion, as opposed to that reason which the Athenians prized so highly.  Yet not only does Euripides portray her as a god-like hero, he even puts as the center of his play a scene in which Medea is granted sanctuary by the king of Athens, somehow incorporating her into the height of Athenian society.  What is going on?

There are many routes one could take in trying to interpret this strange and uncomfortable play, but I am going to focus on the contrast between Medea and the other men in the play, especially Jason.  By all rights, Jason should be the hero of the play.  He is a standard hero of Greek mythology (remember the story of Jason and the Golden Fleece?), and in this play he presents himself as a reasonable (and hence preemenintly virtuous) man.  Yet his reason falls flat, as the audience sees him try to persuade Medea that she should be happy he is divorcing her.  By divorcing her and marrying the daughter of the king of Corinth, he argues, he will give their sons royal brothers and so raise their social standing in this city where they have been exiled.  Medea is, unsurprisingly, horrified by such cold logic, and reminds him of the passion he and she used to feel for each other: passion so extreme that she murdered her own brother to aid Jason in his quest for the golden fleece.  In fact, as she reminds him, Medea is just as much a classical hero as Jason himself is, for it was due to her and her θυμός (thumos) that he was able to complete his quest at all.  θυμός: it’s a complicated Greek word, and one that Euripides often ascribes to Medea.  One might translate it as spirit, in the sense that we speak of a spirited man, but it encompasses much more: the soul, the primary seat of the emotions, a man’s deepest being, desire, passion, a kind of fearless courage exemplified by a great soldier, even anger or fury.  θυμός is one of the primary qualities of a classical hero, such as Achilles.  It is also a traditionally male virtue.  Yet in this play, Medea is the one with all the θυμός, and the male characters seem pretty weak by comparison.  Creon delays Medea’s exile for a day to disastrous consequences (against his better judgement, as he himself admits), and Jason is easily tricked into giving Medea the opportunity to murder his new wife.  Medea alone pursues exactly what she wants and defers to no one and nothing, not even her own motherly tenderness.  She alone follows her passions, rejecting Jason’s shallow reasonableness and social climbing, and summoning up all the spirit and willpower she has, to execute what she sees as her righteous fury.  Medea’s θυμός makes her a classical, as well as a literary, hero.

Let me be clear, I am not trying to excuse or justify Medea’s murder of her children.  But I think Euripides is pushing his audience to imagine what could happen when someone entirely on the outside of society (a woman in a man’s world, for instance) finds themselves abused and mistreated.  Could such a person have hidden depths?  Depths of evil, yes, but also depths of heroic passion?  And could these depths prove such a person to have, in a certain way, a greater spirit than those who mistreated her?

Greek Myth, Gender Roles, and Christian Inversion

Tags

, , ,

The Greek myth of Alcestis tells the story of the ideal of womanly virtue.  King Admetus of Pherae had been granted a strange gift by the god Apollo: upon the day he was fated to die, another person would be allowed to take his place and die for him.  Although his parents were elderly, they were not ready to face death, and so his young wife Alcestis offered herself.  Her great virtue was much praised and did not go unrewarded.  When Heracles visited Admetus on the day of Alcestis’ death, he attended the funeral and beat Death in a wrestling match.  For his prize, he won Alcestis restored to life, with the small condition that she must remain silent for three days.  This she did, and with Admetus lived happily ever after.

To a modern Christian, the story of a person dying in someone else’s place and then being restored fully to life after three days will sound strikingly familiar.  But what I think is more remarkable is the way that the Christian gospel turns the story of Alcestis on its head.  The important difference between the two is the gender of the hero.  In the Greek myth, Alcestis is constantly praised for being the ideal wife.  Her story shows that it is the virtue of a wife to die for her husband, to put her life entirely at his service.  And this is normal in any hierarchy: the lesser person gives their life for the greater.  The wife dies for her husband, the soldier dies for his king, the slave dies for his master.  To die for someone else is to say, “Your life is worth more than mine.”

How radical, then, for Christ to die for the sake of his bride, the church. But this is the call of the Gospel: to invert the world’s hierarchies, to put the greater in the service of the lesser, as Christ himself commands:

The kings of the Gentiles exercise lordship over them, and those in authority over them are called benefactors.  But not so with you. Rather, let the greatest among you become as the youngest, and the leader as one who serves.

Christ dies for those beneath him, and this sets the tone for all of Christian life.  Thus, gender roles in Christian marriage, as described by Paul in Ephesians, overturn the gender roles of the classical world, as exemplified in the myth of Alcestis.  Paul does not act as one might expect him to.  He neither ignores the surrounding culture, in which husbands are greater than their wives, nor does he adopt it.  He doesn’t abolish the system of hierarchical marriage, but nor does he simply instruct wives to serve their husbands and leave it at that.  Rather, following Christ’s example, he turns the hierarchy upside down, instructing husbands to love their wives even to the point of dying for them.  It is no longer the wife, but the husband, whose virtue is to give up their life for their spouse, to say to their spouse, “Your life is worth more than mine.”

Paul’s instructions are emphatically not a misogynistic product of his culture, to be discarded now that we live in a more enlightened culture.  But neither are they an a priori truth, without any relation to his culture.  Rather, they are a microcosm of how the Christian gospel radically engages with and overturns whatever culture or hierarchy it finds itself in contact with.  It inverts the gender roles of the classical world.  Christ plays the role of Alcestis and gives his life for those who are beneath him, and Paul works out a whole new picture of marriage, where the husband serves his wife just as much as (if not more than) she serves him.  Foolishness to the Greeks, indeed, but life-giving wisdom to those on the wrong side of the hierarchy.

Quote

“Refugee Blues” by W. H. Auden

Tags

, ,

Say this city has ten million souls,
Some are living in mansions, some are living in holes:
Yet there’s no place for us, my dear, yet there’s no place for us.

Once we had a country and we thought it fair,
Look in the atlas and you’ll find it there:
We cannot go there now, my dear, we cannot go there now.

In the village churchyard there grows an old yew,
Every spring it blossoms anew;
Old passports can’t do that, my dear, old passports can’t do that.

The consul banged the table and said:
‘If you’ve got no passport, you’re officially dead’;
But we are still alive, my dear, but we are still alive.

Went to a committee; they offered me a chair;
Asked me politely to return next year:
But where shall we go today, my dear, but where shall we go today?

Came to a public meeting; the speaker got up and said:
‘If we let them in, they will steal our daily bread’;
He was talking of you and me, my dear, he was talking of you and me.

Thought I heard the thunder rumbling in the sky;
It was Hitler over Europe, saying: ‘They must die’;
We were in his mind, my dear, we were in his mind.

Saw a poodle in a jacket fastened with a pin,
Saw a door opened and a cat let in:
But they weren’t German Jews, my dear, but they weren’t German Jews.

Went down the harbour and stood upon the quay,
Saw the fish swimming as if they were free:
Only ten feet away, my dear, only ten feet away.

Walked through a wood, saw the birds in the trees;
They had no politicians and sang at their ease:
They weren’t the human race, my dear, they weren’t the human race.

Dreamed I saw a building with a thousand floors,
A thousand windows and a thousand doors;
Not one of them was ours, my dear, not one of them was ours.

Stood on a great plain in the falling snow;
Ten thousand soldiers marched to and fro:
Looking for you and me, my dear, looking for you and me.

On a rainy morning in New York City, we briefly stopped in Poets House, a poetry library where I found this poem that perfectly captured the ideas I talked about in my last post.  The poem is explicitly about German Jews, but by using the blues style of African-American culture, it extends itself for any dispossessed and outcast people.  The swinging, soothing rhythm belies a painful subject, just as the closeness between the speaker and “my dear” belies the distance between them and their homeland, them and humanity, them and nature.  No anger or hope – just a despondent recognition that refugees are never welcome, and that even the animals have it better.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free